Improper management of shoulder dystocia

Article

An Erb's palsy was diagnosed after the delivery of a California infant weighing 9 lb, 8 oz in 1997.

An Erb's palsy was diagnosed after the delivery of a California infant weighing 9 lb, 8 oz in 1997. The patient sued the obstetrician and claimed that negligence during delivery resulted in the Erb's palsy, and that there had been a lack of informed consent regarding a trial of labor due to the risk of shoulder dystocia. She also argued that fundal pressure was improperly used when the shoulder dystocia occurred and that a McRobert's maneuver was not used.

The obstetrician argued that the injury to the brachial plexus was most likely sustained when the shoulder was stuck as a result of uterine contractions and not from any action of the physician. A defense verdict was returned.

Newsletter

Get the latest clinical updates, case studies, and expert commentary in obstetric and gynecologic care. Sign up now to stay informed.

Recent Videos
Haluk Damgacioglu, PhD, discusses cervical cancer's link to anal cancer risk | Image Credit: cadsci.com.
Natalia Llarena, MD, discusses rising fertility anxiety in Gen Z | Image Credit: havingbabies.com.
Uma Mahadevan, MD, highlights new guidelines for managing IBD | Image Credit: ucsfhealth.org.
© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.