Pay-for-performance programs: Are they worth it?

Article

Pay-for-performance programs are proliferating: A projected 155 P4P programs are expected to be in place this year compared with just 39 in 2003.

Pay-for-performance programs are proliferating: A projected 155 P4P programs are expected to be in place this year, compared with just 39 in 2003, according to data from the health-care informatics group Med-Vantage and the Leapfrog Group. Yet some question the value of this growth.

Government officials, for example, have taken issue with these programs: New York State Attorney General Andrew Cuomo expressed concern that these programs could "steer patients to less-expensive rather than high-quality providers," reported Modern Healthcare (9/3/2007). And many physicians already oppose P4P programs; they see these programs as a means to pay doctors less.

Arguably, a report from PricewaterhouseCoopers puts an even bigger ding in the P4P movement. The researchers reviewed 10 different P4P programs and found that they used 60 different physician performance indicators, not one indicator was used by all programs, and no two programs rewarded physicians the same way. The report states, "the wide variation in program structures, performance metrics, and rewards structures mutes (the plans') potential impact." (See the editorial in our November 2007 issue, "Pay for performance: Ready or not, here it comes!" pp. 16-18, or visit our Web site at: http://www.contemporaryobgyn.net/.)

Recent Videos
Baher Mankabady, MD, highlights safety of buprenorphine against OUD in pregnancy | Image Credit: linkedin.com.
Devon Ramaeker, MD
Elizabeth Gandee, APRN-CNP, highlights gaps in women's menopause knowledge | Image Credit: wexnermedical.osu.edu
Doula highlights how postpartum care is failing new mothers | Image Credit: linkedin.com
Nicky Herrick MD; and Anushree Agarwal, MD, MBBS, highlight their study on cardiac arrhythmias in pregnancy | Image Credit: © Igor Borodin - stock.adobe.com.
Lisa Becht, MD, FACOG, sheds light on fertility awareness | Image Credit: havingbabies.com.
First US national HPV conference highlights advances in cancer prevention | Image Credit: uchealth.com.
Mitchell Creinin, MD, reports estetrol pill eases menstrual symptoms | Image Credit: health.ucdavis.edu
1 expert is featured in this series.
Susanna Mitro, PhD, reveals ethnic disparities in uterine fibroid diagnosis | Image Credit: divisionofresearch.kaiserpermanente.org.
Related Content
© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.