Physicians skeptical about public liability database

Article

S

A new national database of medical liability records has raised eyebrows among the medical community. HealthGrades Inc., an independent health-care ratings company, recently launched a database to compile all available public liability records, reported American Medical News (5/21/2007). The database includes closed claims from 15 states (California, Connecticut, Florida, Idaho, Indiana, Massachusetts, Maryland, North Dakota, New Jersey, New York, Oregon, Tennessee, Virginia, Vermont, and West Virginia), as well as information on the outcome (whether it was a judgment, settlement, or arbitration award), and the exact amount or range of the payment, as available.

Although physicians encourage patients to do their research when choosing a doctor, some note that information on medical liability claims provides only a small part of the story. After all, such claims are complex; for example, patients may not understand that some specialties are high-risk and more prone to lawsuits or that a case is often settled because "it is more financially beneficial than a drawn-out lawsuit." There are also concerns that the HealthGrades database may not be accurate and physicians will not have the opportunity to correct misinformation.

Recent Videos
Baher Mankabady, MD, highlights safety of buprenorphine against OUD in pregnancy | Image Credit: linkedin.com.
Devon Ramaeker, MD
Elizabeth Gandee, APRN-CNP, highlights gaps in women's menopause knowledge | Image Credit: wexnermedical.osu.edu
Doula highlights how postpartum care is failing new mothers | Image Credit: linkedin.com
Nicky Herrick MD; and Anushree Agarwal, MD, MBBS, highlight their study on cardiac arrhythmias in pregnancy | Image Credit: © Igor Borodin - stock.adobe.com.
Lisa Becht, MD, FACOG, sheds light on fertility awareness | Image Credit: havingbabies.com.
First US national HPV conference highlights advances in cancer prevention | Image Credit: uchealth.com.
Mitchell Creinin, MD, reports estetrol pill eases menstrual symptoms | Image Credit: health.ucdavis.edu
1 expert is featured in this series.
Susanna Mitro, PhD, reveals ethnic disparities in uterine fibroid diagnosis | Image Credit: divisionofresearch.kaiserpermanente.org.
© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.