Criticism of medical malpractice system may be overblown

Article

That's the conclusion of a recent article in the New England Journal of Medicine (5/11/06). Based on a review of random samples of closed-claim files at five malpractice insurance companies in four regions across the United States, the study's researchers found that "portraits of a malpractice system that is stricken with frivolous litigation are overblown."

That's the conclusion of a recent article in the New England Journal of Medicine (5/11/06). Based on a review of random samples of closed-claim files at five malpractice insurance companies in four regions across the United States, the study's researchers found that "portraits of a malpractice system that is stricken with frivolous litigation are overblown."

The researchers found that meritless claims-those that did not involve injury or error-were not generally compensated. Of the 1,452 claims reviewed, researchers found that 3% involved no verifiable medical injuries, and the vast majority of these cases (84%) went unpaid. Similarly, among the 37% of reviewed claims that involved an injury but were not associated with error, 72% were not compensated. In contrast, 73% of claims involving injury and error were paid.

Although the cost of defending against frivolous claims is not trivial, eliminating claims that involved error would decrease costs only up to 16%. The researchers concluded that "moves to curb frivolous litigation, if successful, will have a relatively limited effect on the caseload and costs of litigation. The vast majority of resources go toward resolving and paying claims that involve errors. A higher-value target for reform than discouraging claims that do not belong in the system would be streamlining the processing of claims that do belong."

Recent Videos
Mirvie's RNA platform revolutionizes detection of fetal growth restriction | Image Credit: wexnermedical.osu.edu
How early genetic testing empowers parents and improves outcomes | Image Credit: tuftsmedicine.org
Dallas Reed highlights trends and barriers in prenatal genetic testing | Image Credit: tuftsmedicine.org
How maternal fetal medicine specialists improve outcomes for high-risk pregnancies | Image Credit: profiles.mountsinai.org
How the cobas liat assay panels improve STI detection | Image Credit: labqualityconfab.
Screening-to-diagnosis interval vital for gestational diabetes outcomes | Image Credit: ultracon2024.eventscribe.net
Henri M. Rosenberg, MD
Medical experts personalize contraceptive options for complex cases | Image Credit: findcare.ahn.org
Study explores the limits of neighborhood data in predicting preterm birth | Image Credit: linkedin.com
Barbed suture reduces blood loss in hysterectomy | Image Credit: linkedin.com
Related Content
© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.